Topic on User talk:Ladsgroup

Hello Ladsgroup,

The user who created the articles in multiple languages for the band Ha*Ash, also added some badges to its wikidata item Q5494459. Deltabot removed the badge for enwiki 4 times, and I removed the badges for eswiki and ptwiki because I couldn't find any trace that the articles really have been granted the 'featured' or 'good' status on those projects. However, Dexbot readded the 'good article' badge for ptwiki. Do you have any idea why, or based on which information?

I'll also leave a message to our pt-colleagues on pt:Wikipédia Discussão:Artigos bons#Ha*Ash.

With kind regards, Mar(c).

Hey,

It's because the article in ptwiki is actually marked as a good article. Maybe it didn't follow the process and someone just added the template but it's in the category: https://pt.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Categoria:!Artigos_bons&pagefrom=Escola+de+Treino+de+Voo+Elementar+N.%C2%BA+1+da+RAAF#mw-pages

The bot works based on the given category.

Thanks for the explanation. Last week I noticed the categorization but I couldn't find the source of it. pt:User:JMagalhães confirmed that it's actually not a good article. The article source text doesn't contain [Categoria:!Artigos bons] or {artigo bom}, so I think the categorization is based on wikidata, via some module (probably pt:Módulo:Categorização AD e AB de outras wikis, and the category wasn't updated after I removed the badge. I'll try again and check the category.

With kind regards, Mar(c).

Yes, removing the badge removed the article from the category: it wasn't shown at the bottom of pt:Ha*Ash anymore. A null-edit to the article was needed to reflect the change in the caterory namespace (https://pt.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Categoria:!Artigos_bons&pagefrom=H).