User talk:Englwik
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Guillaume III de Royn, évêque de Grenoble not relevant request for deletion[edit]
Hello B-noa,
I read your request for deletion Q64779153 Guillaume III de Royn, évêque de Grenoble. I think this request is not really relevant: Gallia christiana dates from 1865; Ulysse Chevalier Notice chronologico-historique sur les archevêques de Vienne dates from 1879 and are both obsolete sources.
- In 1973 Louis Boisset in Un concile provincial au treizième siècle, Vienne 1289: Église locale et société, Editions Beauchesne, Paris, 1973, page 123. writes: "Guillaume III de Royn, bishop of Grenoble 1281-1302: A charter of January 13 1281 enabled E Maignien to identify Guillaume de Royn, as bishop of Grenoble. He belonged to a noble family of the Dauphiné”. The author specifies in note (same page): "Edmond Maignien in Notes historiques sur l'évêché de Grenoble de 1237 à 1388, Grenoble 1877 pages 19-24 corrects previous works, such as Haureau, Gallia Christina: three bishops succeeding each other, named Guillaume II de Sassenage, 1266-1280; Guillaume III de Royn, 1281-1302; Guillaume IV de Royn, 1302-1338."
- Many other sources cite "Guillaume de Royn, bishop of Grenoble" [1].
I hope I haven’t offended you with this clarification (sometime editors are sensitive when a error is indicated to them) 
Have a good day --Englwik (talk) 20:09, 22 July 2021 (UTC)
Remove dubious and meaningless remarks in French from B-noa (off topic). --Englwik (talk) 14:17, 23 July 2021 (UTC)