User:Andrew Gray/sandbox2
Associated with
[edit]| Description | Used to describe a generic association of one item/concept with another, where we don't have a more specific property available |
|---|---|
| Data type | Item |
| Example 1 | Christmas cake (Q556060) → Christmas (Q19809) (qualifier traditional food (Q19708506)) |
| Example 2 | We Are the Champions / We Will Rock You (Q66008229) → News of the World (Q309021) (qualifier subject has role (P2868)="single taken from this album" |
| Example 3 | News of the World (Q309021) → We Are the Champions / We Will Rock You (Q66008229) (qualifier object has role (P3831)="single taken from this album" |
| Example 4 | Handbuch zum Evangelischen Gesangbuch (Q53631328) → Evangelisches Gesangbuch (Q1381294) (qualifier subject has role (P2868)= "Kommentarwerk"/"Handbook" |
Motivation
[edit]This is intended to be used to describe some way in which two items are related to each other, if there isn't an existing property. It can be used with a qualifer (perhaps subject has role (P2868), perhaps a new qualifier property) to specify what that relationship is.
The number of potential ways that something can be related/connected to another concept is very large. We have properties for some of these (eg inspired by (P941), used by (P1535) or based on (P144)) but we are unlikely ever to create properties for all of them.
This is similar to relative (P1038)/kinship to subject (P1039), which we use where one of the standard properties like father (P22) can't cover the specific relationship. Andrew Gray (talk) 19:28, 11 August 2019 (UTC)
Discussion
[edit]
Support Strong support, in and out of the sandbox! Moebeus (talk) 19:51, 11 August 2019 (UTC)- Support We have a need to connect Administrative parishes and Church parishes in Sweden as some information is connected to one of them like the churchbooks to church parishes but the Administrative parish "socknar" has a history of more than 500 years and have been "stable" so they have also a lot of information... it is a weak relation between them and its not 1 <-> 1 and it looks like we have a process were we will get data how they are "connected"/"related"... another option is to do spatial search and find all church parishes near a specific parish but we prefer to have this relation in RDF
- Project discussion
- T199893 "WD: Decide how to connect a "församling" and a "socken" parish" Salgo60 (talk) 09:50, 12 August 2019 (UTC)
- Support I would like this for paintings that e.g. hung for decades in a collection as visual pendants, but which are not pendants in the strict sense of the word, though one maybe ordered to match the other. There are other examples but I can't think of any now. Jane023 (talk) 07:12, 21 August 2019 (UTC)
